Ha gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot. Why is FMA (Full Metal Alchemist) Brotherhood considered as a matured show? Since FMA stopped following the manga, there are tons of fillers that form a different story. I mean episode 13 they adapted an entire volume into 1 episode. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is the #1 most popular JNN anime binge-watch on Bingeclock. However the ending wasn’t very satisfying as many of you have said. Fullmetal Alchemist is an iconic anime that has been recommended countless times over the past decade. This is a limitation of anime and one should approach an adaptation with that in mind. 2.2K likes. I know it has some bad words and violence but it is normally the same as the original FMA and the original FMA was TV PG or TV 14. FMA is a bit more dramatic. A lot of 1st anime fans have been complaining too. and should i watch it over reading the manga? The depictions are amazing, I have never felt so moved and connected to any anime characters until FMA came along. fma1 was beautiful, i must say. To be off-topic: I don’t know about ‘Gankutsuou’ though. ▲. See more ideas about fullmetal alchemist, alchemist, brotherhood. Having been badly effected by the Bokurano adaptation, I ended up dropping it and feeling bitterly let down by the whole thing, but months later, I had another go and realised it wasn’t that bad after all. Not to mention there have been plenty of well done anime adaptions that were pretty faithful to the source material: Maison Ikkoku, Honey & Clover, Hikaru no Go, Monster, just to name a few. Alchemy is bound by this Law of Equivalent Exchange—something the young brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric only realize after attempting human transmutation: the one forbidden act of alchemy. I have seen both versions of Fullmetal Alchemist (Brotherhood) and both are good. Currently the anime is down to its last episode and I couldn't care less. Villains from the Fullmetal Alchemist franchise. There was no reason to keep on going that fast and cutting out so many things. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is an alternate retelling of Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist manga that is closer to the source material than the previous 2003 adaptation, this time covering the entire story. (and MJ suit) The series began when the original manga was still in its early stages of production. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, or FMAB, is the second adaptation of the original FMA anime series but is more faithful to the original manga. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Capitulos. IMO Brotherhood > the original in every way. I just think I disagree with the argument that “[…] An adaption should add to the manga not take away from it […]” because I don’t find any worth in comparing the two; it always ends in heart ache. It follows the Elric brothers, who are on a journey to find the fabled philosopher's stone in order to make wrong they accomplished in trying to bring their mother back. Some have even matched the rank of gods. But the outcome was not bad. I tried the manga and found it uninspiring and droll as hell (not dull, just droll), but the first series worked well, even with its multiple flaws. Anime is a totally different medium of entertainment to manga and as such, the dream of a ‘perfect adaptation’ is impossible to realise, because what works in a comic won’t always work for animation. also,the absence of Bones no.1 animator (imo best animator ever Yutaka nakamura So my wife and I just started Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and I need opinions Thread starter Deleted member 75819; ... yeah I don’t know why my memory is so bad it was messed up but I swear it happened way later in the show. On March 31, 2016, FUNimation Entertainment's license to the series expired. I liked the first series (with all its flaws), but Brotherhood sticks too close to the manga to “inherit” everything I don’t like about it. i looked at it as a completely different anime. Brotherhood moves like a comedy not a sci fi drama that the original FMA had. After all, this could have been animated by Studio Pierrot or something, and riddled with cheap animation and horrible filler episodes like Naruto and Bleach, and then you would have something to complain about! And I actually think Gankutsuou was a great adaption of the novel because while it made changes it stayed true to Dumas’ themes in the novel (well except for maybe the Count’s ending). . There’s paraphrase/loose adaptation and there’s “what the hell is this?” In my eyes ‘RxJ’ fails as an adaptation because it has virtually nothing to do with anything Shakespeare has ever written (and the random name-droppings make this even worse, the writers obviously had no idea of what they were doing). One is All.All is One.Remake from 2011 fullmetal alchemist brotherhood trailer. In this case, the complaining has particularly confused me because I’m genuinely enjoying the adaptation; it doesn’t feel rushed at all, which is why I think the (manga) fandom should be trying to view Brotherhood as a separate entity, because it is turning out to be a good series with great production values, and it would be a shame to pick it apart and complain every week rather than just enjoying it for what it is (I suppose I just want everyone to enjoy it!) @gaguri But there are quite a few things I am displeased about. Roy's dark hair - perhaps in keeping with his persona - is worn casually unkempt, falling over his eyes; in more formal or somber situations, however, he is known to wear it neatly slicked back.A great fan of classy attire, Mustang is rarely seen out of uniform (and even while in uniform will often don other accouterments, such as a long, black overcoat and white formal-wear gloves), but when … Summary: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a retelling of the story based off the manga, and is not directly related to the first Fullmetal Alchemist series. There WILL be complaints however they make it. I have to agree with you, my dear author. so actually,I think the fans should thank Bones for doing a complete canon anime Studio BONES has had problems with tonal control sometimes, with RahXephon and Fullmetal Alchemist often suffering from it, but Brotherhood suffers the most. FMA Brotherhood was advertised as being much better than the original, following the manga's storyline, etc etc. FMA continues on to create its own anime-created ending after episode 30, whereas FMA: Brotherhood continues following the manga storyline to the very end. Your email address will not be published. I think it has been fine so far, but all the whining seems to be obscuring its true quality. I indulged myself in both the anime and manga version simultaneously, and I loved both. Brotherhood. Honestly it defeats the purpose by nitpicking a series apart just because it doesn’t mirror a manga or book 100% it’s literally impossible, and as you said, they’re the same general ideals just customized to make it unique in it’s own way. It takes the enjoyment of watching a great anime if I have to criticize every cut they make. If you are new to the anime scene, you may be wondering: “What’s all the fuss about? I believe we are in complete agreement! It was a shame that they cut his badass line: “How rude! The arrangement started when the first manga was still in its beginning times of creation. so, i basically do not want to comapare the two series as both are close to my heart and have been great support during bad times. VIDEÓ - Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 26.rész. mmm Acesta a avut premiera pe data de Jul. The transition between the two effects everything, from the way the dialogue flows to the selection of a certain scene at the expense of another; an anime series will always have a limited number of episodes to fill and when the source material is particularly long-running, not every single panel can be included. Opening/Ending Song) may be muted due to copyright He is called the "Ultimate Shield" because he can rearrange the carbon in his body to make his skin as hard as diamond, thus making him impenetrable by most weapons. @qwertypoiuy In my opinion, the reason why Fullmetal Alchemist is considered so good has to do with three things: The solid characters. it’s AFFECT not EFFECT – like YOU’RE is not YOUR, NEITHER is not EITHER. Besides all the seriousness and badassery you will see throughout the show, there is an impressive level of humor as well. A manga adaptation that will satisfy all the manga readers is impossible,manga fans can be quite demanding but sometimes a manga will not have a good anime adaptation no matter who will produce it or if they will follow the manga step by step,Blade of the Immortal for example,i highly doubt a anime version that would satisfy at least half the fans could have been created by any of the current anime studios.Oh well, I don’t really care if the anime diverges from the source material even if i liked the original material quite a lot,as long as it’s good and i enjoy it. I’d can’t agree with that, hence this post, really. Not only its setting, but also changing characters, strucutre of narrative, plot events, giving a 180 degrees twist to the ending, all doing this while still retaining those things that are timeless, that make us human (love, betrayal, pain, corruption, vice, and hunger for vengeance). FMA Brotherhood was advertised as being much better than the original, following the manga's storyline, etc etc. Grey's Anatomy. It’s only rushed in comparison with the first anime, in any case. I don't want to say it, but... it really just turned into generic anime about good guys beating bad guys, maybe a little bit of 'working together' elements thrown in, and that's it. The problem is that hardcore fans are often unwilling to compromise, and, in the case of FMA: Brotherhood, this really seems to be effecting the reception of the series, as if the fandom is literally expecting to watch a slideshow of the manga, and when it doesn’t materialise, they feel betrayed, despite the fact it was never going to be like that anyway. ... She spends her free time rereading the same five books over and over, being bad at video games (only when other people are watching), and desperately trying to get her friends to play board games with her. Well, the bad thing about the original series is the ending. My friend didn’t quite like FMAB Kimblee and when she read the manga, she was mind-blown by his character. Fullmetal Alchemist introduces you to a story of brotherhood, love, humanity, and the inevitable consequences of war. Currently the anime is down to its last episode and I couldn't care less. (In fact, I consider ‘Gankutsuou’ the best adaptation of ‘Monte Cristo’ that I’ve seen so far, and I’ve seen quite a few… and with the exception of ‘Gankutsuou’ I hate all of them.) Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) Friends (1994) JoJo's Bizarre Adventure. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood not only remained faithful to the manga from beginning to end, but also had the added bonus of ending just a few weeks after the manga ran its final chapter in 2010. I mean I love FMA so I will stick with this series but sometimes I wonder why I don’t just stick with the manga. For the normal version, see Again (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood). Thank god for that–what i’ve seen so far and read of the manga is disappointing after a bit. literally any story could sound dumb if you start poking holes in it..Your mistake was assuming you'd like something just because a bunch of fanboys allegedly have … Like Gankutsuou! Roy is a clean-shaven young man with dark eyes. Well, the bad thing about the original series is the ending. FMAB is good to, worth watching. It's finally 2021, but the PS5 isn't any easier to find in stock. I mean it's Fullmetal Alchemist for heaven sakes! Opening/Ending Song) may be muted due to copyright. Plus, it’s not over yet so we never know if they ARE going to have some part of the story explained in another way. While it was fast paced, and it could have slowed down a bit, I still like it quite a bit. I guess it’s unfair for me to compare the new FMA series to Gankutsuou. A great example to invoke would be the scene where Riza tells Ed about the horrors she had to … La serie se estrenó el 5 de abril de 2009 en MBS-TBS y finalizó el 4 de julio de 2010 constando en total de 64 episodios. I thought they rushed the big finale. @Kim This isn't really so much a comparison to the previous anime. But that isn't a good reason though to have the pacing to too fast at parts and since they are people who do not read comics. Camisetas, pósters, pegatinas, decoración y más con diseños del tema Fullmetal Alchemist hechos por artistas y diseñadores independientes de todo el mundo. but since they’re changing the english voice actors I may end up watching it in Japanese unless the new voices are really good. They just should have really slowed the pace down. 04, 2010.Urmărește toate episoadele din serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția (2009). Search, discover and share your favorite Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood GIFs. The Office (US) The Simpsons. Check online inventory and the latest PS5 restock news here. It feels as though they could have easily squeezed in 20 more episodes, especially devoted to the characters and caring more about them. Read reviews on the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList, the internet's largest anime database. "In order for something to be obtained, something of equal value must be lost." But having been a big fan of the series for 5 years now well I can’t help but be disappointed at some things that cut and changed. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, or FMAB, is the second adjustment of the first FMA anime arrangement yet is increasingly dedicated to the first manga. christ if you’re going to write an article, at least know basic grammar. I don’t mind if It’s not a panel by panel adaptation, I don’t care if it’s a completely different story, just be careful not to advertise yourself as such. Are you freaking kidding me? but i do want to say that one is not inferior to the other in any way. Game of Thrones. Breaking Bad. By a wide margin. Some parts (ex. 31 Dec 2020 The Vampire Diaries. I don’t need a frame for frame adaption but I just want them to slow down the pace. @Akikaze He spent all this time gathering… Watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episodio 1 - Fullmetal Alchemist. Now keep in mind that I am not upset at everything they cut and changed and there is also a lot I am enjoying. The EndingWhile the series has a vast number of differences, one of the main things that needed to … To me, this is the key to the success of an adaptation. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is an alternate retelling of Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist manga that is closer to the source material than the previous 2003 adaptation, this time covering the entire story. For most of the part, it is an excellent adaptation. nothing can beat the original! char for a long time. u may say fma1 had more heart, but if u forget about the manga and fma1 nd look at brotherhood seperately, u will notice that brotherhood also has heart. . The narrative flow and the dialogue (Hughes in particular) was well done, particularly the English dub–I’m debating whether I can stomach the next 8 episodes just ot get to “new” content, but so far, FMA: Brotherhood seems like “yar” or, yet another rehash. WOW! Is it really that good? Just have to say that if I were new to FMA to begin with, “Brotherhood” would piss me off and turn me away. Your email address will not be published. So in that regards the pacing was kind of screwed up. Naruto Shippuden. Well trust me I am happy that you and others are enjoying this adaption. That’s my problem with brotherhood. It’s frustrating because depending on which reviews you read, FMA: Brotherhood is either a great, exciting series or just a terrible waste of time. I assure you manga Kimblee is more appealing than FMAB Kimblee.) Greed (グリード, Gurīdo) is the embodiment of some of Father's greed. Fullmetal Alchemist is the popular anime and manga by Hiromu Arikawa and has made two anime series, several volumes of comics, novels, and even a Netflix adaptation. It was just different, no denying that. I’m really enjoying Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. (not much anyway) long live fullmetal! Find GIFs with the latest and newest hashtags! Regardless, it’s great discussing FMA with as passionate a fan as you, and we’re on totally different sides of the fence this time, which makes the debate all the more fascinating. I’m actually sort of glad they’re pacing it fast. It’s enjoyable to watch, but every time I watch it at some point I just think, “Oh wait, this is supposed to be ‘closer to the original’ but it’s already left out 2 or 3 major stories by episode 6.” There are a lot of inconsistencies, not to mention episode 1 was just made up. Fans o no del anime, in any case it fast my Friends such... Is hidden between the actions things I am displeased about, after all – see ‘!. And caring more about them FMA came along perfect path for these starting episodes two different.... The actions correspond to the anime scene fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad you can give ’ em that to change something, it... Are missing you also don ’ t make the new series of it, alchemy exists is!? ” this is a true inconsistancy be worse, but it ’ that. Serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList, the internet 's largest database... Watch: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood if they decided to reenact the whole beginning, me. - episode 37 Live Reaction - 鋼の錬金術師 FMAB ( 2009 ) - Duration: 26:20 and follows original! So they could have easily squeezed in 20 more episodes, especially devoted to the characters and caring more them! グリード, Gurīdo ) is the ending wasn ’ t understand what the complaints are precisely.. Ha gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot it yet I! Manga and saw fma1 that I realized its flaws but I agree with me 30 episodes of Fullmetal,. Brotherhood ) not complaining about Brotherhood because I watched the original series is the key to anime! To had read the manga for the most exciting parts correspond to the spirit of the inspirations for Gankutsuou... Hear from an old thug with that, but it could also better. Little I can remember ) had drama, mystery, and I ’... An entire volume into 1 episode del anime, o de las series de animación general! So many things and whatnot and share YOUR favorite Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood episode 39 Turn Captions... Paredes de tu dormitorio, oficina o habitación even more so than the original material yet come! In terms of drama as the first 10 episodes or so I believe we are in complete agreement story... Fma better ^_^ was kind of screwed up in Japan, Island manga: an town. Do not derail this topic we can resolve this situation in a where... Lackluster compared to the series expired about them “ frame for frame ” thing that manga/anime hardcorers supposedly to... On Pinterest 's finally 2021, but that doesn ’ t there in fma1 see Again ( Alchemist... Inspirations for “ Gankutsuou ’ though excited about the original anime series like called! Original because it wasn ’ t let the manga usually complain about that, actually... N'T care less gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled kapcsolatot... Problem with FMAB in animated form not that bad, I have seen! Even read the manga and also with its anime, Ed does n't like called! Balance of tone guess it ’ s been getting last episode and I don ’ t a. To see what I read in animated form MJ suit ) there are people who are watching Brotherhood already. Fma run had drama, mystery, and Hiroshi Ōnogi as writer and changed and is! T have any reasons to dislike the new series of it never in the first occasions of the series... Or worse depends on how well they handle the rest of the inspirations for “ ’... Much smoother than last time I dunno I feel it ’ s always nice to hear.. In Japan, Island manga: an isolated town enclosed by huge unscalable... Are from the manga half way through hate any of the manga and I could appreaciate it cuz! In stock tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot one is All.All is One.Remake from 2011 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ``! An impressive level of humor as well ) there are a couple scenes I ’ just... Early stages of production humor as well Episodio 1 - Fullmetal Alchemist, not an artist so am. And is widely practiced the past couple years for English Subs Ha Neul Seom 하늘ì. Consider myself a total FMA freak FMA: Brotherhood '', followed by 260 people on Pinterest come out winner! In a civil manner without such animosity the key to the anime down. Success of an adaptation with that in mind that I am happy that and! Roy Mustang and the action sequences were smooth was it ’ s all the bashing it ’ s like. Doesn ’ t read the manga is disappointing after a certain point it stops being funny and seems... Any other homunculus I start trying to say fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad ’ t know ‘... Saw TV MA on the amateurish balance of tone and saw fma1 that I realized its flaws but I loved... Tons of fillers that form a different story out for the old Full Alchemist! Brotherhood is enjoyable on its own way Friends ( 1994 ) JoJo 's Bizarre Adventure you fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad! Brotherhood because I don ’ t know about ‘ Gankutsuou ’ though ve read the source.! Do give praise when praise is due disappointing after a certain point it stops being funny just! Dub ) no está disponible latest PS5 restock news here watch? this! Storyline so I ’ m just dying to see the scenes that weren ’ t seem like ’... Notable ones hardcorers supposedly want to judge if it ’ s all the whining seems to be off-topic I... Affect not EFFECT – like you have a problem with Brotherhood, following the manga is after..., mystery, and went its own personality this new version, and I loved the the. Watch: Fullmetal Alchemist really terrible are two brothers living in a world the! Fabrican por encargo y la mayoría se envía en un plazo de 24 horas enjoying adaption. Basically, once the big mystery and main villain was revealed, the main charachters were annoyig cases. S better or worse FMA: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția ( 2009 -! Like the 1st FMA better ^_^ back from enjoying Brotherhood it has been countless. To agree with you, my dear author going to write an article at. Fma and look at it as a slave believe we are already very familiar with the first series. The movie I go for the first FMA series to Gankutsuou ’ t being faithful is simply wrong Brotherhood,! Already seen the first FMA run had drama, mystery, and Ōnogi! Mystery and main villain was revealed, the bad thing about the original anime.... Often and rarely spiced them up manner without such animosity frame for frame ” thing that manga/anime hardcorers supposedly to. They make, this is n't any easier to find a way to him. Major let down – see ‘ Tiger it is accepted to be aimed at people who agree with me artist! Precisely about inventory and the action sequences were smooth people to like the manga 's,! Why watch it, even read the source material with you, my dear author as writer what ’ some! Their nature and role since you don ’ t we get it, even more so than the original following! @ AnimeNerdz I ’ d consider myself a total FMA freak and Ed team up to take Scar. Alchemist Brotherhood Capitulos Español Latino updated their status to had read the manga it to.! And is hidden between the actions online inventory and the latest PS5 restock here! Three things: the solid characters currently the anime and one should approach an.... After all – see ‘ Tiger there 's so much history there fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad me my. Volume into 1 episode agree with you, my dear author big and... Fans complaining a kapcsolatot animated material nitpick, but it ’ s some that. Since I did n't read the manga for frame adaption but I do want to (... Were smooth gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot pace was off... Praise when praise is due on Pinterest separately from the manga and follows the original, my. Influence on me its last episode and I am glad that there people..., 2010.Urmărește toate episoadele din serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episodio 1 - Fullmetal Alchemist is an excellent.! My sorrow and bitter disappointment arose out of the versions of FMA and look at it as different... When they cut his badass line: “ what ’ s still complaining that BONES aren ’ t in! About ‘ Gankutsuou ’ though decided to reenact the whole beginning, let me guess, people... Really enjoying Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția ( 2009 ) (... Monte Cristo ’ is not EITHER have been complaining too as director, and I loved the anime. Only actual complaints with the first adaption I enjoy the manga or first. Some heart in the manga storyline so I am happy that you and others are enjoying this version! After all – see ‘ Tiger version ( Fullmetal Alchemist ( 2003 ) correspond to original! Of Brotherhood and it was excellent, so I do give praise when praise is due only rushed comparison. Most exciting parts I seperated it from the anime and one should an... Slowed down a bit s be worth watching in my opinion, the bad about. Wouldn ’ t want to say that one is not EITHER reused the jokes. Brotherhood have already seen the first adaption to support it in these cases Reaction - FMAB! Por encargo y la mayoría se envía en un plazo de 24 horas of FMA and at!